When You’re Tempted to Leave Unschooling and Try Something Else

26 April 2022

Every evening of our recent holiday, Imogen and I swished through the warm waves as we walked along the beach, waiting for the sun to set.

One evening, I noticed a group of birds on the sand. At first glance it looked like a gathering of seagulls, but there were two imposters in the lineup.

The word imposter makes me think of all the times I’ve felt like an unschooling imposter. For many years I’ve blogged, podcasted, written books and made videos about this way of life, sharing my thoughts, my ideas and my family’s stories. And it might sound like I know everything and our life is perfect. But we’ve had our share of difficult days, days when I’ve questioned what we’re doing, days when I haven’t felt qualified to share unschooling with anyone. I’ve just wanted to run away from my life and my public presence on the Internet. Yes, I’ve felt like an imposter hiding in a line of real unschoolers, hoping no one will notice I don’t belong.

It took me a while to realise that everyone has bad days, even unschoolers. The problem is not many people talk about them. It’s much easier to share the good times. And having difficult days doesn’t mean we’re on the wrong track. It’s not unschooling that is making life hard. We shouldn’t look around at what other people are doing and then try something else. Oh no, we need to stick together as a family, love and forgive and help each other through the problems, and keep trusting.

I wrote the following words in my story An Unschooling Imposter:

It’s all very well loving each other when our days are perfect. That’s easy. But when things aren’t so good, can we continue loving each other? For example, can we choose not to take offence when someone treats us unfairly but instead try to understand and be forgiving? Can we pull each other up again when we fall? Can we help each other become the people we are meant to be? If we can, then, even if everything is not looking and feeling as we’d like, we’ll be unschooling perfectly.

Life will never be perfect. It will always have its hard times whether we unschool or not. But it’s unschooling that will help us deal with them. We could say:

Unschooling is the perfect way of life, especially when life seems far from perfect.

Our holiday was perfect. All the problems of an imperfect life felt a million miles away as I spent a few days relaxing on the beach with my daughter.


An Unschooling Imposter can be found in my book Radical Unschool Love. The new edition of my second unschooling book will be available on Amazon very soon. I ordered the proof copy a couple of days ago. If it looks okay when it arrives, I’ll be able to immediately hit the ‘publish’ button!


So, have you ever been tempted to jump off the unschooling ship on a bad day? Have you ever felt like an imposter? And do you have a place to retreat to when the problems of the world seem overwhelming?

4 Comments Leave a Reply

  1. Hi Sue,
    It’s Sandie here – I always love reading your blogs. I often think of jumping off the unschooling bandwagon as such….at the moment most days….. but I’m still here… why? That’s a big question!
    Thank you for sharing… we were in a conversation on another forum…. which I think you have now left as I can’t find our chat. You asked for my email which I hadn’t quite gotten around to sending to you. Will you get it via this comment? I hope so!

    • Sandie,

      Maybe unschooling calls to our hearts because at its core is unconditional love, and that’s why we stay even on the bad days! Whatever the reason, I’m glad we’re both still here, and I’m so pleased you stopped by to comment. Oh yes, I now have your email address. Thank you. I hope we can stay in touch!

  2. Thank you for sharing, Sue! Yes, I definitely have days like this too. Lately, I’ve had lots of those. It’s good to know I’m not alone in that.

    • Sarah,

      I smiled when I saw your comment! It’s been a long time since we last chatted. I’ve been thinking about you and your family and wondering how you are. I’m sorry to hear you’ve had lots of difficult days recently. Oh yes, it’s good to know we all experience hard times. We can encourage each other!

Please add your thoughts!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Previous Story

Could a Lack of Freedom Damage Our Kids’ Mental Health?

Next Story

What’s the Best Place to Bring Up Kids?

Go toTop

Discover more from Stories of an Unschooling Family

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading